Create Account
Forgot Password?

Updating Mobile Technology for Astronomy Students

Proposal ID 2006-034-1
Department Astronomy
Non-core Access Campus unit gets priority
First Application? Yes
Student Initiated? Yes

Abstract

We request funds to update our pool of iBook laptops. These computers are approaching
four years of age and are quickly growing obsolete. Originally purchased with funds provided
by STF grant 2002-417, these laptops are among the most used resources available to astronomy
students. They have accompanied students around the world to many professional meetings
and serve as valuable tools for public outreach. Additionally, these laptops have been employed
actively in astronomical research, and are loaded with specialized software allowing observations
(e.g., using the 3.5m telescope in NM) and data analysis.
We stress that these laptops have accompanied students for extended periods of time (up to months)
and are equipped with specialized software, which requires demanding installation procedures. Thus,
we propose to maintain these computers separately from the Classroom Services Support pool.

Background

Modern science dictates the need for computing mobility: astronomers are often found on the road.
Unfortunately, such mobility is harder to come by for
astronomy students. Both undergraduate majors and graduate students have greatly benefited
from the laptops purchased with STF grant 2002-417. Yet in the four years that we have been
using these machines, their age has begun to show. These laptops are first-generation Mac G3/600MHz
computers with 128MB of memory, and the Mac OSX places significant stress on the hardware.
Furthermore, the old G3s are unable to show modern mpeg movies without severe jerking and
discontinuities, which is an increasing problem as animations become more essential in presentations and public
outreach. These machines have proven their value in many situations, and in order to maintain
this level of excellence, we are proposing the purchase of six laptops to replace our aged fleet.

The Astronomy Department student community consists of 24 graduate students and 61 undergraduate majors.
We rank nationally among the best Astronomy departments in the country, due in large part to our student
research and
presence at professional meetings. The laptops provided by the STF
have enabled these students to produce professional-grade presentations and deliver them to future employers.
Since most meetings are at least four days, the ability to check-out a laptop for an extended period of time
is critical. Furthermore, collaborations often require long-term visits, and these laptops have accompanied
students for research trips lasting months at a time.

In addition to professional meetings, these laptops have been an integral part of the
general exam process in the Astronomy Department. The general exam consists of one week of intensive study (outside of any class) on
a topic related to a student's thesis, followed by a colloquium level presentation. The ability to have a laptop
for an entire week enables the student to collect and organize the presentation, and deliver the
final product without the concern of file or system transfers.

The research that fuels these presentations also often dictates the need for mobile computing. The UW
Astronomy Department is a senior member of the Astrophysical Research Consortium, which owns and operates the 3.5m telescope at
Apache Point Observatory (APO). During the past four years, no less than 20 students have been involved with
research performed at APO. Our department has engineered software to remotely control this telescope. This
software, in turn, has been installed on our laptop pool, enabling students to observe from anywhere on Earth.
This allows for greater ease in scheduling, since a given observer is not required to be at the University
or at the observatory. Securing time on the telescope, which is a competitive process and costs $5K
per night for operations, demands interface reliability.
Unfortunately, we expect an increasing hardware failure rate as the student laptops age.
In addition, the analysis of astronomical data requires technical software, such as
the Image Reduction and Analysis Facility (IRAF) and the Interactive Data Language (IDL), which have been installed
on the laptop pool.

The computers provided by STF grant 2002-417 have been maintained, well-traveled, and critical to
the success of astronomy students. In light of the STF committee's past decisions on laptops, which
have often opted for the use of the central UW pool, we will demonstrate that the need for
extended check-outs, along with necessary specialized and proprietary software, justifies the need to update the
current astronomy laptop pool.

Benefits

Updating the laptop pool available to astronomy students will greatly improve the present
situation. The current pool of laptops is four years old and is at the end of its
useful tenure. This period of time is comparable to replacement cycles employed here at the
UW (see 2003-072, 2004-024,and 2005-007) and extends well beyond the the one-year warranty offered by Apple.
Of the original six STF-funded iBooks, five remain in a functional state. Those remaining are struggling mightily
under the current operating system and research and presentation software. Since the
original laptops' G3 processors are more than two times slower than current models,
this situation will not improve.

The laptops serving the Astronomy Department have been a valuable commodity to our students.
Our original proposal, 2002-417, illustrated the astronomy student's need for mobile computing,
specifically for professional presentations. During the four years we have had these laptops, their use
has been broad and extensive.

For instance, these laptops have traveled all over the world, including: <br>
<ul>
<li>Albuquerque, NM - American Astronomical Society (AAS) meeting (2002) <br>
<li>Ascona, Switzerland - 2005<br>
<li>Aspen, CO - National Virtual Observatory Summer School (2005) <br>
<li>Austin, TX - Society for the Advancement of Chicanos and Native Americans in Science meeting (2004)<br>
<li>Baltimore, MD - Space Telescope Science Institute (2004,2005)<br>
<li>Banff, Alberta, Canada - Western Regional Nuclear & Particle Physics Conference (2005)<br>
<li>Brussels, Belgium - 2004<br>
<li>Cornell, NY - Division of Dynamic Astronomy meeting (2003)<br>
<li>Dublin, Ireland - 2005<br>
<li>Flagstaff, AZ - Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) meeting - 2003<br>
<li>Kyoto, Japan - 2005<br>
<li>Las Vegas, NV - Dynamics of Galaxies: Baryons and Dark Matter meeting (2005)<br>
<li>Milan, Italy - 2005<br>
<li>Minneapolis, MN: AAS meeting (2005)<br>
<li>Moffett Field, CA - NASA Ames Research Center (2004)<br>
<li>Orlando, FL - National Society of Black Physicists/National Society of Hispanic Physicists (NSBP/NSHP) meeting (2004)<br>
<li>Philadelphia, PA - 2005
<li>Pittsburgh, PA - SDSS meeting (2004)<br>
<li>Portsmouth, England - SDSS meeting (2005) <br>
<li>San Jose, CA - NASA Harriet G. Jenkins fellowship meeting (2005)<br>
<li>Sunspot, NM - (multiple times) Apache Point Observatory<br>
<li>Terschelling, The Netherlands - Island Universes meeting (2005)<br>
<li>Tokyo, Japan - 2005 <br>
<li>Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada (multiple times)<br>
<li>Washington, DC - NSBP/NSHP meeting (2004) <br>
</ul>
In addition to being used at professional meetings, these laptops have
had a profound impact on the UW campus. As discussed above, the laptops have been
extensively used in preparation of graduate student general exams. Furthermore,
these computers have found a variety of uses in public outreach programs. These include
the Astronomy Department open house, public talks, K-12 outreach, and multimedia presentations for
students traditionally underrepresented in Astronomy as part of our
<a href="http://www.astro.washington.edu/premap/index.php">Pre-MAP</a> (Pre-major in
Astronomy) program. These uses have been an unexpected, but welcome, addition to
those originally outlined in STF proposal 2002-417.

Finally, we wish to emphasize our need for a laptop pool maintained separately from the
central campus pool. Each of the trips listed above were longer than the maximum of three days now
available to students through the
<a href="http://www.washington.edu/classroom/computing/stf.html">Classroom Support Services pool</a>,
with some being up to two months long.
Additionally, specialized software such as IRAF, IDL, and the
3.5m Telescope User Interface (TUI), which are commonly used by
astronomy students, requires intensive installation procedures. Having to install this
software each time a student checked out a laptop could easily consume one day, severely
restricting the amount of work a student could accomplish. Thus, in order to maintain
the high level of productivity of our students, updating the current
laptop pool is essential.

Student Access

These laptops will be housed in the Astronomy Department Office on the third floor of
the Physics and Astronomy Building. Astronomy students will have access to these computers,
along with physics students working with astronomy professors. Students may check out these
laptops by signing them out, for a maximum of one week. If more time is needed, the student
may petition the staff for an extended check-out period. The laptops will be available on a
first-come, first-served basis. A calendar will be provided in order to check out laptops in
the future. This system is currently in place with the laptops from STF proposal 2002-417 and
has performed very well.

Available Resources

<i>Computing</i>: The Astronomy Department currently houses a significant computing network.
The computing system is composed of about 80 PCs running Linux. These PCs form the core of our Condor system
(see 2002-405,2003-062,2006-010), and
along with a 64 processor Astrophysics Cluster, two 12 processor clusters, and gigabit Ethernet comprise
the backbone of the Astronomy Department's hardware resources. In addition, we have a wireless network and
five iBook laptops provided by STF funds. Note that one of the original six iBooks purchased with STF
funds has suffered a hardware failure.

<i>Accessories</i>: In order to provide protection for the laptops while traveling, we request shoulder bags
for transport.

<i>People</i>: Senior graduate students (John Bochanski and Rok Roskar) have volunteered to maintain and manage
these laptops, with the assistance of the office staff.

<i>Space</i>: The laptops requested in this proposal are mobile and simply require a secure file cabinet for storage.
This will be maintained by the Astronomy Department Office.

Installation Timeline

There are no restrictions on the installation of these laptops. They will be purchased immediately
upon receipt of necessary funds.

Departmental Endorsement

"The Department fully endorses this proposal for STF Funds.

The first-generation laptops were initially instrumental for training the graduate students in the technology of digital
presentations and spreading the technology to every facet of our program: their research presentations at international
meetings, operating our $10M telescope in New Mexico remotely over the Internet from wherever the student users happen
to be, talks in classrooms on campus and in K-12 schools and to the public, and for a multitude of other purposes.
Indeed, the technology of digital presentations took root quickly in the ranks of the graduate students four years ago
and--like much other new technology-- spread rapidly from them to the faculty ranks. As it turns out, the research
software is quite a load for the old G3s to bear!

Replacements for the present old laptops will catch the next wave of computing technologies and operating systems, allow us
to obtain reliable hardware, and open more doors to new types of presentations and other applications. Much of our
software, which pushes the old G3s to their limits, will fit comfortably on the new units. The popularity of the
laptops is such that we can expect to need even more units than proposed here, so the Department will do its best to
help out as our needs become clearer." - Bruce Balick, Chair of Astronomy Department

Student Endorsement

This proposal is student initiated and student written. After polling the current graduate students,
we found that over 90% have used the original STF iBooks. This does not include those who have graduated in the
past four years. Thus, this resource ranks among the most used in the Astronomy department. We
invite the committee to read the Comments section for additional student endorsements.

Items

Below are the items making up the current proposal. The asterisk (*) beside items signify that they were approved by the committee. This however was not implemented correctly for our database before 2005, so earlier years may not show this.

Click an item's title to view details on that item, or show all item details.

TitleTypePriceQtySubtotal
Apple iBook Laptoplaptop-mac$899.996$5,399.94

Location: Physics / Astronomy Tower - C319

Description: Apple G4 iBook / 1.33 GHz / 512 MB ram / 40 GB HD / wireless and bluetooth capabilities

Justification: Enables mobile access to necessary software for the astronomy student. This allows extended professional visits, as well as providing remote observing and analysis capabilities. Note that these laptops will seamlessly integrate with the existing wireless network and run X11 applications, which are commonly found in Astronomy.

Laptop Bagsother$29.996$179.94

Location: Physics / Astronomy Tower -

Description: Laptop Shoulder Bags

Justification: To provide protection for laptops while traveling.

Taxtax/shipping$491.031$491.03

Location: Physics / Astronomy Tower -

Description: 8.8% Tax

Justification: Pay the Man.

Requested Total: $6,070.91
Approved Total: $2,023.64
Funding Status: Partially Funded

Comments

Having presented many talks using the old fleet of Mac laptops, I can say that they are crucial to the training of graduate students in the art of delivering scientific talks. Unfortunately, the processors are too wimpy to adequately present the high-resolution images and videos which have become common place in modern astronomy. It is high time that they be replaced with faster counterparts.

I have used the Astronomy Department's laptops on too many occasions to count. Simply put, they have been invaluable, whether for giving talks and working at meetings, or for much longer visits to collaborators. I have taken a laptop with me to make presentations and/or work on data, papers, or proposals at week-long meetings in Orlando, San Diego, San Jose, Vancouver, Washington, DC, and Austin. I also spent two months a year ago at the Hubble Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore with one of the laptops, without which I would have done very little--as a relatively short-term visitor to the Institute, no local computing resources were available to me.

Sadly, in four short years the laptops have aged considerably, and they are groaning under the weight of the data-analysis and other specialized software packages that we require. Replacing the laptops will allow undergraduate and graduate students to continue using this much-appreciated and extremely useful resource.

I have used the department's laptops for public outreach programs and informing students about the Pre-Map program. The old technology isn't able to keep up with the data-intensive things we want to show. These laptops have been around the world and have many specific software titles that aren't available on the UW general laptop pool and are too expensive for me to put on my personal laptop. If I give a talk in Japan, Washington DC, or Italy, I need to have an Astronomy Department laptop.

The astronomy laptops have been critical for allowing me to hone my presentation skills in the department and abroad. Having access to a laptop has been immensely useful for giving formal presentations at scientific meetings and, perhaps more importantly, for sharing my ongoing work with collaborators during meetings and visits to their host institutions. An STF-funded laptop enabled me to work productively on a 2 month visit to NASA Ames -- this visit has led to an ongoing 3 year collaboration which has had a vast impact on the direction of my research. Without access to an astronomy laptop which I could check out for a such a long term trip, I would have been vastly less productive, and ultimately may not have been able to sow the seeds for such a lasting research collaboration.

Unfortunately, the laptops are getting long in the tooth, and now even the creation of standard powerpoint presentations taxes their abilities. Refreshing the STF astronomy laptop pool will enable the graduate population to continue their professional development in the years to come.

Please replace the laptops. It has gotten painful to watch presentations where slides take minutes to appear and people wonder whether the computer has crashed or the computer is just really slow. In most cases, some herky-jerky movie shows up that the presenter assures us was really cool when they saw it on their desktop computer. I'd really like to be able to see the movies in their full, cool form.

Seriously, this is very unprofessional. Many students need to take these laptops to professional meetings for several weeks to show their work. The laptops in the department are the only presentation option for many students. If the presentations can only be made with these computers, I can assure you that potential employers and other audience members will not be impressed by the technical prowess of the University of Washington. This is truly a sad state for a university located in a city that prides itself on its technical accomplishments. New laptops are so cheap.

The astronomy laptop pool has been one of the most valuable professional resources we possess. These community laptops have ensured that all of our students are equipped to give presentations at professional meetings as well as to continue working on important research while travelling. Unfortunately, these laptops have become outdated, and they are no longer as useful as they once were. In order to keep these a valuable resource, we must replace them with newer models.

One of the department laptops recently accompanied me on a three week long trip to meet with a research group in Japan. During my time there, I presented two talks to the astronomy group at Kyoto University using the department laptop. I also demonstrated our telescope remote control software for the Japanese group using the laptop, where easy remote access to the telescope was a key factor in influencing them to collaborate with us. The comment made above regarding the now-outdated processors is correct, however-- i had a hair-raising moment right before one of my talks where the laptop struggled to open my not-usually-processor intensive presentation. If it weren't for a handy USB stick and the fact my advisor had a newer generation Mac laptop with her, I might not have been able to give my talks. Needless to say, that would not only have looked unprofessional in general, but would have made our department look extremely bad in front of a culture that prizes functional technology. The department laptops are an absolutely indispensible resource, but even our best maintanance efforts can't prevent their becoming a liability with age. Please help us to replace them and keep our department on the cutting edge.

I am writing in my capacity as a professor of Astronomy, major advisor for several graduate students, and Director of the Apache Point Observatory in New Mexico where the UW operates and owns a 30% share in a 3.5m telescope. The student laptops that were purchased several years ago with STF funds have been extremely important in the educational experience of our graduate students. The ability to observe remotely from Seattle or elsewhere using the laptops means that the students have greater flexibility and access to the telescope than at any of our partner institutions (Princeton, Chicago, Johns Hopkins, etc.). We have much higher graduate student participation in both thesis and auxiliary research programs partly as a result of this ease of access which is also an important aspect of our graduate training in observational astronomy.

In addition, the emphasis on professional high-quality presentations at conferences and during collaborative research visits cannot be
overstated. By having access to state of the art laptops, our students have earned a reputation for being extremely well-prepared and giving excellent talks, which enhances both their postdoc job prospects and the reputation of UW Astronomy as one of the premier graduate programs in the country. The return from the orginal STF proposal has been outstanding. The very modest investment requested here will have a truly major impact on the graduate experience of our students.

Dr. Suzanne Hawley (Professor of Astronomy, and Director, Apache Point Observatory)

It would be very nice to have modern Macs to be able to check out when going to conferences. The existing laptops aren't capable of running astronomical software like IRAF and IDL and are really only useful as (slow) powerpoint projectors. It would be great to be able to continue working while on the road.

As an Astronomy Grad student, I can vouch for both the usefulness of the laptops, and their age. These computers are incredibly handy because they can run the software necessary to handle the full spectrum of our responsibilities, from outreach to research to presentations and staying in touch from national and international meetings. There really aren't any events in our department that lack these computer's glowing white apples. The current laptops have served us well, but the hardware is starting to fail, current software (noticably Powerpoint) runs *extremely* slowly, and data storage needs have grown beyond their hard drives. In terms of the spectrum of non-class activities, and the heavy use, this is a great investment for the STF fund.

As a graduate student, I have used the old STF funded laptops at conferences around the world (Las Vegas, Vancouver, Switzerland, England). While it was great to have a laptop for these extended trips, they have been most helpful to me around the department. One night, I was scheduled to remotely observe with the 3.5 meter telescope in New Mexico. Unfortunately, there had been a catastrophic crash in the department computer room, and all the regular computers were down. Because we had our own set of laptops, I was able to quickly install the necessary software and observe without a hitch. These laptops will serve a vital role for students in the department.

As an astronomy graduate student, I have used the old laptops extensively. They have traveled with me to meetings both domestically and abroad, I have used them for presentations in classes, and I have used them to put together my general exam presentation. They have been invaluable. However, I also found that the speed at which I worked while doing my general exam was limited by the speed of the laptops. When more than one application was open, the computer stalled for minutes at a time, sometimes nearing 20 minutes! Please don't let this valuable resource be such a limiting factor in our productivity and professional appearance. For this resource to remain valuable, it must be upgraded. Please fund a new set of laptops.

The old iBooks get used and used a lot by the graduate students in astronomy. These students do more than just work with drop-down menus. Being Unix-based, these iBooks are an extension to nearly all of the programs and applications the graduate students use. The graduate students use the iBooks to explain their research, to extend their knowledge from the office to the observatory, to reach out to the public about astronomy. The iBooks definitely need to be replaced.

Note: This cannot be undone.